Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Do you hold off on technology that could damage morale?


With so much technology out there to track employees’ every move, companies need to consider not only the cost of such technology in dollars but in potential damage to their culture of trust.

We have 110+ counselors out on the road every day, running from client to client to support them with independent living and vocational skills.  We’ve divided our territory into regions and make schedules to minimize travel time but it is an incredibly difficult job.  Staff have to maintain a very reliable vehicle on a modest salary and on a typical day they may battle traffic in bad weather, navigate a rough neighborhood only to arrive to support someone only to find their home infested with bed bugs.  It is not for everyone.  One of the strategies we have to combat turnover is to foster a company culture that celebrates and values these direct support employees.  We are firm in our mission and hold field staff up as crusaders for our cause.  This culture has served us well.

We’ve always struggled with tracking employee time and attendance.  Most of our staff start and end their day out in the field.  We had no choice but to do timesheets on the honor system.  There was not way to install time clocks in all the private homes we visited.  To support our model, we frequently do random quality assurance calls to our clients to make sure our staff are providing the supports they are reporting to us and all clients work with a team rather than just one employee to diminish the opportunity for fraud.  Any staff person found to be taking advantage of our honor system faces our zero tolerance policy.  They have to go…since we work with vulnerable individuals this is one area in which we cannot compromise.

Now we have technological options to track our staff.  A few years ago we considered voice recognitions call in to time clocks but that was too expensive.  Now our payroll system has affordable aps for smartphones.  Employees can log into a time clock from anywhere with their smart phone and it will log the GPS location so we can confirm they are at the designated client’s home when they log in and out.  This would virtually eliminate our need to trust staff—technology will track their every move.  Nearly all of our employees have their own smartphone so the cost to use this type of time and attendance system would be very small.  It would probably result in a cost savings since it would eliminate the possibility of employees inflating their hours or reporting they are working when they are not.  It is a no brainer…or is it? 

We have created a culture around these jobs—they are our most valuable players, our front line face to the community who carry our or mission every day, often under very difficult circumstances.  We build them up, celebrate their value and reward their accomplishments at every opportunity.  This is key to retain them.  How can we implement a technology that completely contradicts everything we say, because the technology screams, “WE DON’T TRUST YOU!”

We could roll it out with a big sell about going paperless and eliminating the need to do timesheets.  We could even promote how it could “protect” staff against the occasional accusation from a confused client who claims they we a no show when they did in fact receive visit.  These are tough sells.  We could say, “Hey, if you are where you say you are, what you have to worry about?”  It all feels a bit creepy, especially when our current system works relatively well.  I think we will pilot the system with a single team and determine its impact on savings vs. any negative impact on morale.  Can implementing tracking technology damage employee trust and a fragile yet extremely valuable corporate culture? In this case, could implementing a new technology increase cost long term?

1 comment:

  1. When our company deployed mobile data terminals in our field force's vehicles we encountered exactly your predicament. The GPS chips in the terminals fed real time location data back to dispatch so that suddenly we knew which crews were at work locations and which ones were parked at Royal Farms. The benefits far outweighed the negatives, as the field forces adapted to the new accountability, and the visibility that the back office now had allowed for more agile and flexible routing of work. I say go for it. It's not a matter of losing trust, it's a matter of being accountable. The "good" ones are always happy to see the rule breakers get caught.

    ReplyDelete