Friday, May 17, 2013

Mobile Robostaffing: The Terminator and Reframing the Public Debate


Recently the Wall Street Journal reported that scientists are conducting experiments with robots in New York and California classrooms with students in need of individualized instruction as the guinea pigs.  The goal is to determine if the robots will be able to teach math, reading, and nutrition (nutrition?) effectively on a one-to-one basis to enrich learning.  The robots range in cost from $1,500 to $14,000 for an android (Hollander).  The experiment is a public lightning rod for critics of robotics, specifically robot staffing, who warn that reliance on robots to engage in tasks as well as relationships that traditionally happen with and among people erodes away at the core of what it means to be human—the face to face connection that builds community and sense of belonging.  One parent, commenting on the use of robots in the classroom, referenced the "Terminator" movies, “in which intelligent robots take over the world and hunt humans.”  (Hollander) Hollander also quotes Sherry Turkle, author of “Alone Together:  Why We Expect More from Technology and Less of Each Other” in commenting "It could be the greatest robot in the world, but a robot teacher still won't understand what is going on in these human interactions."  It is important to recognize that robots should never fully take the place of the role of real human interaction.  However, keeping an eye on this important relationship should not deter us from pursuing exploration of the positive applications for the technology, and apparently recently it’s not.  According to one analyst, “Mobile robots are reaching a level of price/performance that is driving a surge of market activity and corporate interest.”  (Fenn) That said, in anticipation of more lightning rods appearing on the public scene such as the robotic teaching aides, the public debate needs to be reframed from good or bad (evil) for humanity to that of opportunity cost:  as our society has evolved, how will not keeping current with application of technology erode at our human experience and inhibit reaching our maximum potential.   How can this technology enhance and improve our common human experience?
It’s unfortunate that America’s fascination with mobile robots seems to have shifted from curiosity to fear as emulated in Star Wars’ C3PO vs. the more recent Terminator referenced by the scared parent.  C3PO introduced America to robot staffing in the form of a mobile android made out of metal and wire with compelling human expressions and behaviors.  Since Star Wars, there has been an increase in use of “fixed” (Gartner) robotic technology in manufacturing industries (especially automotive) but only very recently with mobile robostaffing technology.  Gartner projects that “over the long term ‘robot staffing’ on business and society is likely to be profound.”   In recent years most progress with robostaffing technology applications has been happening quietly behind the scenes in the military, space, and medical fields.  Finding rescuing injured soldiers during military operations or collecting atmospheric samples for NASA outside the International Space Station (NASA) are but two examples of recent evolutions of this technology.  According to Gartner, historically fixed robot technology has been mined most successfully in manufacturing, allowing people who would have worked engaging in tasks that are likely mind numbingly and often dangerous routines opportunity to find work elsewhere (where is a question for another blog).  Due to advances in R&D, mobile robots are actually problem solving, learning, and behaving like people, and looking forward there is significant potential for this technology to drop the cost floor as “new services are made available that were previously too dangerous to undertake” and I would add, too “human” to undertake such as our classroom aides.   
Reframing (or merely focusing) the public debate over use of robotics from one of good vs. evil to that of opportunity cost may help alleviate the public pressure that may distract from the focus on how private and public investment in mobile robot technology can enhance our human lives. 
Real life isn’t as black and white as Star Wars or the Terminator.  Is use of robotics a “bad” thing for all industries and so for humanity?  Is it always a “good” thing?  The answer is neither; robotics as a technology can be used by humans for good or bad just as weapons or a Facebook post can.  The question America needs to be asking is not whether this is “good” or “bad” but how this technology can be used to enhance human experience, and what is the opportunity cost in failing to invest fully.  In the meantime, I look forward to reading about the real life results of the robostaff classroom aides and keeping my fantasy good/evil framework for the movies.

Fenn, Jackie.  “Mobile Robots Carry the Internet of Things Into New Opportunity Areas.”   December 14, 2011.

Fenn, Jackie and Raskino, Mark.  “Hype Cycle for Strategic Business Capabilities.”  July 31, 2012.  Gartner.

http://my.gartner.com/portal/server.pt?showOriginalFeature=y&open=512&objID=260&mode=2&PageID=3460702&id=2100615&ref=

Hollander, Sophia. “When a Teacher is 2 Feet Tall:  School Experiments Use Robots as Learning Tools; a Dragon for Lifestyle Tips.”  Wall Street Journal April 11, 2013.

Nasa Website:  http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/main/robonaut.html 

No comments:

Post a Comment