Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Key Takeaways - N. McLean


1. Avoid the Hidden Decision Making Traps

What? There are many hidden decision making traps that people/executives make when making decisions.  The six traps, anchoring, status-quo, sunk-cost, confirming evidence, and framing, are the psychological traps that will undermine business decisions.

So What? Bad decisions can destroy a career and even a business.  The article that we read noted that these bad decisions could be traced back to the way the decisions were made.  Thus, it is important to recognize the traps and guard against falling for them.   

Now What? Knowing that these six traps often undermine decisions of business professionals, I will be cognizant that they exist and try to avoid making them.  I think the anchoring trap is one I often fall for the most, especially in my trading.  Going forward, I will try to always look at the situation from different angles, be open-minded, and recognize anchoring traps while negotiating.  Also, I will try not to influence my teammate’s decisions by telling them as little as possible so they can form their own opinions to make the best decision. In addition to preventing myself for falling for these traps, I will try to educate my teammates of these traps.  Hopefully this will make us better decisions makers and we can all demand better decisions and point out potential traps. 

2.Use the Space

What? In the face of ambiguous threats, organizations tend to be passive and do nothing.  As we saw in both the Columbia and Sony cases, when faced with an ambiguous threat, the people, the management teams, and the organization as a whole did NOTHING.  There was a real issue facing these organizations and instead of being proactive and addressing the issue immediately, they were passive and failed to actively tackle the problem. 

So What? Failing to face ambiguous threats with urgency can lead ultimately to the demise of an organization.  In Sony’s case, they lost $2 billion in market cap and lost the respect and trust of the clients, business partners, and stockholders.  In the case of Columbia, seven people lost their life and the reputation of NASA was permanently damaged.  Therefore, ambiguous threats are real and can create massive bottom-line issues and reputation damage if not addressed.

Now What? Use the “space” actively and efficiently.  If there is a window of time to gather data, ask questions, perform tests, hold meetings, think, respond, etc. – do so!  Whether the space is 1 minute, 2 days, or 1 year, I will try to use the time to act and make effective decisions.  It is understandable that people act passively when faced with an ambiguous threat, but I will apply this lesson immediately and try to act.  Yes, threats can be very difficult to deal with and it is easy to avoid it by pretending they don’t exist, but this is even more costly than trying to address the problem and failing. I will challenge myself and my team to always use the “space” to make decisions to avoid avoiding ambiguous threats. 

3.But why? Yes, but why? I know, but why?

What? Always ask why three to five times to drill down to get better evidence, better data, and better information. Do not just settle for the information the first time it is proposed. 

So What? This statement is very critical because it demands the best data and really makes one drill down to facts to get to the heart of the matter.  This routine betters the company because the decisions that are made are based off well thought out ideas and are looked at from all different angles.  Proposals aren’t just accepted as fact, but they are challenged and thoroughly analyzed. 

Now What? This takeaway is essential and can be put into my everyday practice.  Every meeting, project planning decision, new platforms, new markets to be traded, etc needs to be challenged with the question, “but why?”  I know I often just agree with a proposed idea or solution because I assumed he or she has done the research.  However, this isn’t always the case and having more discussion and digging deeper can lead to better results.  Asking why three times is an easy thing to demand and it will challenge my teammates to ensure we are making the best, thought out decisions for our stakeholders.  Also, knowing that the best decisions that are made are the ones that are challenged and deeply analyzed, I will ask myself why before proposing ideas to the group. 

4.Data-Information-Knowledge-Wisdom

What? Information systems convert data to information, information to knowledge, and knowledge to wisdom to improve decision making. 

So What? This statement is critical to understanding how an IT system is able to help and aide decision makers.  Data is a powerful tool and can ultimately lead to information, to knowledge, and ending with wisdom.  With the wisdom, you are hopefully able to add value to a firm and make profitable business decisions to gain a competitive advantage.  The example we used in class was very powerful – how just giving your date of birth can lead to information about preferences, how to structure a marketing campaign, sponsors, etc.  

Now What? Therefore, going forward I will demand the best IT systems and data which will hopefully parlay into wisdom (applied knowledge).  I often overlook the benefits of certain IT platforms and take them for granted.  Going forward, recognizing this, I will strive to always use and have access to the best data and information systems which will ultimately bring success and achievement because I will be making informed and profitable business decisions.  

5.MOT – Management Organization Technology Triangle

What? The MOT triangle is crucial to assess/address the alignment of the management, organization, and technology.  Management is responsible for developing the strategic direction and the leadership of the firm.  The organization revolves around the people, culture, and HR practices of the firm.  And technology can be used as a strategic partner to gain a competitive edge.   

So What? There must be alignment between the business strategy and also the IT strategy.  Further, the organization must embrace and align with the management goals and technology.  If there is any sort of misalignment, the organization will not operate efficiently.  Using the Danone case, the organization didn’t embrace technology because it didn’t mesh well with its culture.  The management team recognized this and sought other ways to achieve sustainability.  

Now What? Knowing how important it is to have all three elements aligned, I will always try to apply this triangle to assess the alignment at my firm.  I often find that our organization is the part that is always lagging behind.  We take the mentality of, “well this is how we have always done it, so we should continue to do it this way.”  And because of this mentality, new technology is not embraced.  In order to change this, I think there needs to be a top-down approach with incentives to pull the organization along to achieve overall alignment.  It is also my role to make sure people are seeing the value in technology and then benefits it will offer.  In addition, if a certain project is implemented but isn’t being embraced, I can use this simple model to see where the stumbling blocks are and try to correct it.  Or if I want to try to get a new process put into production, I know I must get all three aspects aligned and on board. 

 

             

No comments:

Post a Comment